Old Mill Tavern Menu (Update 2026)

Old Mill Tavern offers a diverse menu that satisfies every craving. Enjoy the classic Shrimp n' Wings category, with shrimp starting at just $5.49. For wing enthusiasts, the Spicy Breaded Bone-In Wings provide a kick for $9.89. Salads and soups add a fresh touch for about $5.15, showcasing delicious options like Dinner Salad and Soup of the Day.

Don't miss the appetizers, featuring 23 mouthwatering choices including the Old Mill Sampler and Crab Cakes. Sandwich lovers can indulge in French Dip or Burgers starting at $6.34. With 65 plates available, Old Mill Tavern blends affordability with variety—ideal for a casual family outing or a night out with friends.

Old Mill Tavern Menu image 1
Old Mill Tavern Menu image 2
Old Mill Tavern Menu image 3
Old Mill Tavern Menu image 4

Featured Dishes

Beer
Beer
Nachos
Nachos
Pretzel
Pretzel
Bloody Mary
Bloody Mary
blt
blt
Gyro Double Meat
Gyro Double Meat
Saucy Chicken Wings with Ranch Dressing
Saucy Chicken Wings with Ranch Dressing
Buffalo Shrimp
Buffalo Shrimp
Hamburger
Hamburger
Sweet Potato Fries
Sweet Potato Fries
Margarita
Margarita
Crab Cake 1
Crab Cake 1
Taco Salad
Taco Salad
Wine
Wine
Cheeseburger & Fries
Cheeseburger & Fries
Burger and Fries
Burger and Fries
Hot Crispy French Fries
Hot Crispy French Fries
Butter Garlic Parmesan Wings
Butter Garlic Parmesan Wings
Rack of BBQ Ribs with French
Rack of BBQ Ribs with French
Fish Sandwich
Fish Sandwich
Old Mill Tavern

About Old Mill Tavern Interior, Food, Ambiance

The interior of Old Mill Tavern exudes charm with twinkling Christmas lights that create a festive ambiance year-round. The laid-back vibe encourages guests to relax while enjoying live music or a fun round of karaoke. Outdoor seating allows patrons to take advantage of Florida's beautiful weather.

Diners encounter a warm, welcoming environment where the food is as impressive as the ambiance. Whether catching up over a plate of wings or launching into a lively sing-along, Old Mill Tavern fosters a community feel that keeps locals coming back.

Old Mill Tavern

About Old Mill Tavern Food and Specialties

Old Mill Tavern stands out for its relaxed atmosphere and tasty food. Diners rave about the Grouper Sandwich and Catfish, which highlight the local seafood scene. Food enthusiasts appreciate the dedication to quality and freshness, making each meal memorable.

The Old Mill Sampler is a highlight, perfect for sharing or enjoying solo. For those looking for something heartier, the Gyro and Chicken Tenders never disappoint. Seasonal specials and unique additions like jalapeno peppers keep the offerings fresh and exciting, catering to local tastes and preferences.

Old Mill Tavern

Old Mill Tavern is committed to providing exceptional food and service. Specialties like the grouper and catfish showcase the tavern's dedication to quality ingredients and local flavors. The vision here revolves around creating a gathering place where the community can connect. With a focus on fun and engagement, live music, and karaoke nights foster an inclusive atmosphere. Each visit aims to leave guests feeling satisfied and eager to return.